The Difference Between A Consent Order And A Clean Break

 

I am going to try and unravel some of the mysteries and misconceptions about a financial order. Many people ask, what is the difference between a consent order and a clean break order.

Some call it a ‘consent order’. Some call it a ‘clean break’. Those imposed by the court are ‘financial remedy’ orders.

So what is the difference?

A clean break is a consent order that basically orders a “clean break” between the parties. It means there are no ongoing commitments between the parties. This may include for maintenance or an order in regards to a property being sold etc.

Consent order means you are both agreeing to make a clean break. You will not make any further claims on each other’s finances now or in the future.

Dont get confused!

Difference Consent Orders Clean Breaks

People can get confused and think a consent order is the same as a clean break. It isn’t. The consent order is an application to the court.
The clean break is exactly what it says on the tin. But you can have partial clean breaks

A clean break should be where neither party can return to the court to have the order varied. If circumstances change in the future and one party want the order relooked at.

But not everyone can have a clean break and so going back to court in the future will always be an option. This is what scares people and what they do to try and avoid it. But it is not always possible but it doesn’t mean your spouse will apply for a variation either.

There are different financial headings that need taking into account

  • Property
  • Capital
  • Pensions
  • Maintenance for children
  • Maintenance for spouse
  • Inheritance

So, if you have sold the house, split the savings and there is no need for maintenance. you are going to share the joint pensions. You would have a full ‘clean break’
Can you see, you have divided everything now. Neither of you would have a cause to go back to have it varied.

But if your house is not sold for another 5 years because the children are young. Or because the market is not good right now, then you have an order that can be varied.

Imagine a spouse is paying £200 spousal maintenance for 10 years. Gets made redundant 2 years after the order comes into force. that person has to go back to ask to have it varied. With no income, one cannot expect to be paying the same as when they were working.

Child Maintenance

One thing people are not made aware of is the terms around the child maintenance. So let me explain. The order will stipulate the payment and for how long. It will also take into consideration any increase year on year. But what is ordered actually only has a life of one year ‘should’ the circumstances change. You don’t go back to court for a variation, you have it assessed by the CMS. The courts could not handle the number of variations it would receive. Life does not stand still and neither do the costs of our children’s upbringing.

The arguments I hear about what the child maintenance is for is amazing. Some parents agree that they are responsible for all the costs. Including school trips and extracurricular activities. Others, only want to pay the least they are by law required to. So the child will either miss out, or, the parent will go the extra mile. Ensuring the child can carry on with the activity.

What one feels is wrong another feels is acceptable. The art is to accept what you cannot change. In doing so it allows the children to escape the arguments the parents may have on the subject.

Spousal Maintenance

Spousal maintenance is a topic that fuels many people. It is calculated similarly to that of a benefit when someone applies to the Government.
Imagine this. The wife keeps the house which has £100,000 equity with no mortgage. The husband is about to retire and can cash his pension getting 25% tax free. This particular pension is worth £1.2 million. The wife has not worked for the past 25 years. The husband is about to start a new consultancy job earning £7000 pcm. How could the wife survive if there was no spousal maintenance? Answer is, she could not. And a Judge would not allow any proposal if there was no mention of spousal maintenance. I hope you can see it would be unfair.

But a financial remedy is where you have failed to come to an agreement with your spouse and apply to the court. There are usually 3 dates to attend court. This may be cut down to 2 and if you still cannot agree. The Judge will impose the decision.

Don’t let a complete stranger called a Judge decide what is going to happen to your money. Give me a call to discuss you financial settlement on 0800 177 7702 or complete the Online Enquiry Form.

Call our Divorce Law Experts for an initial consultation on

0800 177 7702 or contact us online

Need Advice? Contact Us